Banking » Investing » Robo-Advisors vs. Self Directed: Which Is Best For Your?
Advertiser Disclosure This website is an independent, advertising-supported comparison service. The product offers that appear on this site are from companies from which this website receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). This website does not include all card companies or all card offers available in the marketplace. This website may use other proprietary factors to impact card offer listings on the website such as consumer selection or the likelihood of the applicant’s credit approval. This allows us to maintain a full-time, editorial staff and work with finance experts you know and trust. The compensation we receive from advertisers does not influence the recommendations or advice our editorial team provides in our articles or otherwise impacts any of the editorial content on The Smart Investor. While we work hard to provide accurate and up to date information that we think you will find relevant, The Smart Investor does not and cannot guarantee that any information provided is complete and makes no representations or warranties in connection thereto, nor to the accuracy or applicability thereof. Learn more about how we review products and read our advertiser disclosure for how we make money. All products are presented without warranty.

Robo-Advisors vs. Self Directed: Which Is Best For Your?

Assess the advantages and challenges of robo-advisors versus self-directed investing for tailored wealth building.
Author: Baruch Mann (Silvermann)
Baruch Mann (Silvermann)

Writer, Contributor

Experience

Baruch Silvermann is a financial expert, experienced analyst, and founder of The Smart Investor.  Silvermann has contributed to Yahoo Finance and cited as an authoritative source in financial outlets like Forbes, Business Insider, CNBC Select, CNET, Bankrate, Fox Business, The Street, and more.
Interest Rates Last Update: June 3, 2024
The banking product interest rates, including savings, CDs, and money market, are accurate as of this date.
Author: Baruch Mann (Silvermann)
Baruch Mann (Silvermann)

Writer, Contributor

Experience

Baruch Silvermann is a financial expert, experienced analyst, and founder of The Smart Investor.  Silvermann has contributed to Yahoo Finance and cited as an authoritative source in financial outlets like Forbes, Business Insider, CNBC Select, CNET, Bankrate, Fox Business, The Street, and more.
Interest Rates Last Update: June 3, 2024

The banking product interest rates, including savings, CDs, and money market, are accurate as of this date.

We earn a commission from our partner links on this page. It doesn't affect the integrity of our unbiased, independent editorial staff. Transparency is a core value for us, read our advertiser disclosure and how we make money.

Table Of Content

Investors often find themselves uncertain about whether to choose robo-advisors or self-directed investing due to several factors. Each option offers distinct advantages and challenges.

Robo-advisors provide ease of use, automated portfolio management, and lower fees, appealing to those who prefer a hands-off approach. Conversely, self-directed investing offers more control and customization, attracting investors who want to actively manage their investments and make decisions based on their research.

Which of them is better for your needs? Let's compare their unqiue advantages and differences.

Robo-Advisors Basics

Robo-advisors are digital platforms that offer automated investment management services using algorithms and minimal human intervention. Users input their financial goals and risk tolerance, and the robo-advisor creates a tailored investment strategy, typically diversifying funds across various asset classes.

These platforms are known for their low fees, ease of use, and 24/7 accessibility, making them particularly appealing to novice investors or those with smaller portfolios. Also, Robo-advisors handle tasks like portfolio rebalancing and tax optimization efficiently.

While they provide a convenient and cost-effective way to invest, they may lack the personalized touch a human advisor can offer, especially for complex financial situations.

Pros
Cons
Low Fees
Limited Investment Options
Accessible
Lack of Personalization
Automated Investing
Limited Human Interaction
Transparency
Inability to Adapt to Complex Situations
Low Minimum Investments
Risk of Technical Issues
May Offer Tax-Optimization

Self Directed Basics

With self-directed investing, investors take complete control of their investment decisions without the guidance of a financial advisor. Investors choose their assets to build a portfolio, including stocks, bonds, ETFs, and other investment vehicles.

This approach suits those who prefer hands-on involvement and have a good understanding of the financial markets. While it offers the potential for higher personal satisfaction and lower costs in advisory fees, it requires a significant time commitment for research and ongoing portfolio management.

Pros
Cons
Control
Risk of Losses
Lower Costs
Time and Effort
Flexibility
Lack of Expertise
Learning & Empowerment
Behavioral Biases

Self-directed investors must stay informed about market trends, analyze investment opportunities, and understand their own risk tolerance.

Robo-Advisors vs. Self Directed: Key Differences

Understanding the key differences between these two investment strategies is crucial for individuals to align their choices with their financial goals, risk tolerance, and preferred involvement level.

Aspect
Robo-Advisors
Self-Directed Investing
Decision-Making
Utilize algorithms to make investment decisions
Investors make all investment choices personally
Involvement Level
Low; offers a hands-off approach to investing
High; requires active management and research
Costs
Generally lower fees compared to traditional advisors
Depend on Use: there are trading fees, but no advisory fees
Expertise Required
Minimal; user-friendly for beginners
Requires a good understanding of financial markets
Customization
Limited; offers standardized portfolios
High; allows for tailored investment strategies
Risk Management
Automated adjustments to portfolios
Requires personal monitoring and adjustments
Support and Guidance
Structured investment path with minimal interaction
Investors must independently seek information and make decisions
  • Decision-Making: Robo-advisors use algorithms to make investment decisions, whereas self-directed investing requires the investor to make all investment choices personally.

  • Involvement Level: Self-directed investing demands active involvement in researching and managing investments, while robo-advisors offer a hands-off approach, automating the investment process.

  • Costs: Robo-advisors typically charge lower fees compared to traditional investment advisors, but self-directed investing can potentially minimize costs even further, avoiding advisory fees altogether.

  • Expertise Required: Self-directed investing necessitates a deeper understanding of financial markets and instruments, whereas robo-advisors require minimal investment knowledge, making them accessible to beginners.

  • Customization: Self-directed investors have greater flexibility to tailor their portfolios to specific preferences or interests, while robo-advisors offer standardized portfolio options based on risk tolerance and investment goals.

  • Risk Management: Robo-advisors automatically adjust portfolios to align with market conditions and the investor's risk profile, while self-directed investors must manually monitor and adjust their investments.

  • Support and Guidance: Robo-advisors provide a structured investment path with minimal human interaction, whereas self-directed investing lacks this scaffold, placing the onus on the investor to seek out information and make informed decisions.

When Robo-Advisors May Be A Good Idea?

Robo-advisors can be a particularly good choice over self-directed investing in several scenarios:

  • You Have Limited Investment Knowledge: For those new to investing or with limited financial market knowledge, robo-advisors provide a straightforward entry point, offering portfolio management based on proven investment theories without the need for deep market understanding.
  • You Have Time Constraints: Individuals who lack the time to regularly monitor and adjust their investment portfolios will benefit from the automated management robo-advisors offer, handling all aspects of portfolio rebalancing and adjustments.
  • You Prefer a Hands-Off Approach: Investors who prefer a set-it-and-forget-it style of investing will find robo-advisors appealing as they automatically manage investments based on the user's goals and risk tolerance.
  • You Need Access to Advanced Strategies: Robo-advisors can offer sophisticated investment strategies, like tax-loss harvesting and global diversification, which might be complex for a self-directed investor to implement effectively on their own.

When Self Directed May Be A Good Idea?

Self-directed investing may be a good idea over robo-advisors in several scenarios:

  • You Want Control: If you prefer having complete control over your investment choices and enjoy making decisions based on your research, self-directed investing allows you to select individual stocks, bonds, or other securities based on your analysis and convictions.
  • You Have The Right Knowledge To Start On Your Own: For those with a strong understanding of the financial markets and investment strategies, self-directed investing provides the opportunity to apply this knowledge to manage and optimize your portfolio actively.
  • You Need A High Level Of Customization: Self-directed investing is ideal if you want to tailor your portfolio to include niche markets or specific investment themes that are not typically offered by robo-advisors.
  • You Want Low Fees: If you're focused on minimizing costs, self-directed investing can save you money on management fees, as you're not paying for the automated advice or portfolio management services of a robo-advisor.
  • You Want to Trade By Yourself: If you're interested in trading individual stocks or engaging in more sophisticated investment strategies like options trading, self-directed investing gives you the platform to execute these trades.

FAQs

Consider your investment knowledge, time availability, risk tolerance, and whether you prefer a hands-on or hands-off approach to make this decision.

Yes, you can switch from using a robo-advisor to self-directed investing by transferring your assets or cashing out your investments, though you should consider potential tax implications or fees.

To start with self-directed investing, open a brokerage account, set an investment budget, define your strategy, and begin researching and selecting investments.

Yes, experienced investors can benefit from robo-advisors, especially for a hands-off, diversified, and automated investment approach.

Typically, no. Robo-advisors generally invest in a mix of ETFs or mutual funds to create a diversified portfolio, not individual stocks.

Robo-advisors typically charge a percentage of assets under management, often ranging from 0.25% to 0.50% annually, which is generally lower than traditional financial advisors.

Yes, like any investment, there is a risk of losing money with robo-advisors, as they invest in the financial markets which can fluctuate.

Yes, self-directed investing can be time-consuming as it requires ongoing market research, investment decision-making, and portfolio monitoring.

Picture of Baruch Mann (Silvermann)

Baruch Mann (Silvermann)

Baruch Silvermann is a financial expert, experienced analyst, and founder of The Smart Investor.  Silvermann has contributed to Yahoo Finance and cited as an authoritative source in financial outlets like Forbes, Business Insider, CNBC Select, CNET, Bankrate, Fox Business, The Street, and more.
Search
Banking Reviews
Best Banking Accounts
Savings Accounts
Top Offers From Our Partners

PNC bank logo

Promotion:
Up to $400 Open a new, select Virtual Wallet product and receive $500/$2,000/$5,000 or more in qualifying monthly direct deposits within 60 days to earn a $100/$200/$400 bonus.
Subject to state availability
PNC Virtual Wallet ® is available in AL, AZ, CA, CO, DC, DE, FL, GA, IL, IN, KY, MD, MI, NC, NJ, NY, NM, OH, PA, SC, TX, VA, WI, and WV. Virtual Wallet ® is offered in the state of MO with the exception of the Greater Kansas City area. Product availability may vary based on where you open your account and the Zip code of your primary address.

Chase_logo

Promotion:
$300 New Chase checking customers enjoy a $300 bonus when you open a Chase Total Checking® account and make direct deposits totaling $500 or more within 90 days of coupon enrollment.. Expired on 7/24/2024
Chase Overdraft Assist
With Chase Overdraft AssistSM, you won’t be charged an Overdraft Fee if you’re overdrawn by $50 or less at the end of the business day OR if you’re overdrawn by more than $50 and you bring your account balance to overdrawn by $50 or less at the end of the next business day

UpgradeLogo

Fees:
No monthly fees No monthly fees and no overdraft fees. Plus get reimbursed for ATM fees with an active account 
Rewards:
Up to 2% cash back Up to 2% cash back on common everyday expenses for active accounts with monthly $1,000 direct deposit, and up to 1% cash back for other purchases 

Promotion:
$300 Use Promo Code “AXOS300” for a $300 bonus when you apply for a Rewards Checking account
Up to 3.30% APY
to get the maximum rate (up to $50,000) you’ll need monthly direct deposits of $1,500 (0.40% APY), 10 transaction on your debit card (+0.30% APY), average daily balance of $2,500 on Axos Invest Managed Portfolio (+1.00% APY), average daily balance of $2,500 on Axos Invest Self Directed Trading Account(+1.00% APY) and make full monthly payment on loans (mortgage, personal and auto) with Axos account (+0.60% APY).

penfed personal loan

APY on Daily Balances
0.15% APY on daily balances of less than $20,000 or 0.35% APY on daily balances of $20,000 up to $50,000
Get paid up to 2 days early
Set up direct deposits and get your paycheck up to 2 days early

Promotion:
Up to $4,000 New customers may earn up to $4,000 when they open an eligible HSBC Premier checking account from January 8, 2024 through March 27, 2024 and complete qualifying activities:

• Receive a cash bonus of $1,500 when you deposit or invest $100,000 – $199,999.99

• Receive a cash bonus of $2,000 when you deposit or invest $200,000 – $299,999.99

• Receive a cash bonus of $2,500 when you deposit or invest $300,000 – 499,999.99

• Receive a cash bonus of $3,500 when you deposit or invest $500,000+

• Earn an extra $500 when you set up recurring monthly Direct Deposits totaling at least $5,000 for 3 months
Wealth Products & Advice
Get access to wealth products, insights and advice from an HSBC Financial Professional through HSBC Securities (USA) Inc
Advertiser Disclosure
The product offers that appear on this site are from companies from which this website receives compensation.

#1 In Banking

Our Newsletter

Get expert advice, insider tips, fresh banking promotions and rate changes on savings accounts and CDs

Banking Promotions & Latest Rate Updates

Our Banking Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter and gain access to expert advice,
insider knowledge, and exclusive updates