When it comes to choosing a store card that maximizes rewards, the Target Red Card and Macy's Credit Card stand out as contenders. Both cards aim to entice shoppers with enticing perks, but a closer look reveals distinctions that might sway your decision.
Target vs. Macy’s Credit Card : General Comparison
The Target RedCard keeps rewards simple, focusing on Target purchases. Cardholders get an instant 5% discount on all purchases, whether shopping in-store or online.
This is a great perk for regular Target shoppers, especially if you're furnishing your home, stocking up on groceries, or keeping up with the latest fashion trends.
RedCard holders also enjoy free shipping on most Target.com orders, making it an even better option for online shopping.
On the flip side, the Macy's Credit Card offers a more detailed rewards program with a tiered system. You earn more points in categories like dining, groceries, and gas.
Plus, Macy's cardholders get access to additional perks, such as discounts, surprise savings, and exclusive free shipping events. For frequent Macy's shoppers, this rewards structure can lead to more significant long-term benefits.
Top Offers
Top Offers From Our Partners
Top Offers
Cashback Analysis: Which Card Gives More?
Based on our analysis, and assuming all supermarket and gas purchases are made via Target – the Target Red Card card will drive you more cash back:
|
| |
|---|---|---|
Spend Per Category | Macy's Credit Card | Target RedCard Credit Card |
$15,000 – U.S Supermarkets | 30,000 points | $750 |
$4,000 – Macy's | 20,000 points | $40 |
$5,000 – Restaurants | 15,000 points | $100 |
$4,000 – Travel
| 4,000 points | $40 |
$4,000 – Gas | 8,000 points | $80 |
Total Points / Cashback | 77,000 points | $1,010 |
Estimated Redemption Value | 1 point ~ 1 cent | / |
Estimated Annual Value | $770 | $1,010 |
* Assuming all supermarkets purchases made via Target
Additional Benefits: Target vs. Macy’s Credit Card
The Target card offers many extra shopping benefits for cardholders, such as exclusive deals, extended return time, and free shipping.
On the other hand, Macy's credit card provides member exclusive savings and perks, birthday surprise and free shipping.
Macy's Credit Card
Star Passes: Exclusive savings reserved for cardholders, providing special discounts on purchases.
Star Money Bonus Days: During these exclusive periods, cardholders can accelerate their rewards accumulation, making their shopping experiences more rewarding.
Birthday Surprise: Cardholders receive a delightful birthday surprise as a token of appreciation.
Member Exclusives: Enjoy bonus points when shopping for your favorite brands and other exclusive perks available only to cardholders.
Free Shipping at Macy’s with your card:
- Silver Tier: Free shipping on purchases of $25 or more.
- Gold & Platinum Tiers: Enjoy free shipping with no minimum purchase requirement, enhancing the convenience of online shopping for cardholders.
Target RedCard Credit Card
- Free 2-day shipping: Enjoy the convenience of swift delivery with free 2-day shipping on an extensive selection of items when shopping on Target.com.
- RedCard Exclusives: Gain access to special items and exclusive offers available only to RedCard holders, enhancing your shopping experience with unique perks.
- Extended Return Time: Benefit from an additional 30 days for returns and exchanges at Target, providing flexibility and peace of mind for your purchases.
- Starbucks Discount: Save 5% on your purchases at any in-store Starbucks location when using your Target Red Card, adding an extra perk for coffee enthusiasts.
- Specialty Gift Cards Savings: Receive a 5% discount on specialty gift cards for travel, restaurants, movie tickets, and more, allowing you to save on a variety of experiences and purchases beyond Target.
When You Might Prefer The Target RedCard?
You might prefer the Target Red Card If:
Frequent Target Shopper: If you find yourself regularly shopping at Target for everyday essentials or special items, the Target Red Card's consistent 5% discount on every eligible purchase can quickly add up, offering immediate and reliable savings.
Simple and Instant Savings: If you prefer a straightforward rewards system without the complexity of points and tiers, the Target Red Card might be your go-to choice. Its 5% discount at checkout provides instant savings without the need to track points or navigate a tiered structure.
Top Offers
Top Offers
Top Offers From Our Partners
When You Might Prefer The Macy's Credit Card?
You might prefer the Macy's Credit Card If:
Diverse Shopping Habits: If your shopping preferences extend beyond Target and include a variety of brands and products, the Macy's Credit Card offers a more versatile rewards system. Its tiered structure allows you to earn points on a broader range of purchases.
Frequent Macy's Shopper: For those who regularly shop at Macy's, the Macy's Credit Card provides an opportunity to capitalize on the tiered rewards system, potentially earning more substantial discounts and perks based on your annual spending.
Compare The Alternatives
If you're looking for a store credit card with great rewards for online shopping – there are some good alternatives you may want to consider:
|
|
| |
|---|---|---|---|
Costco Anywhere Visa® Card by Citi | Apple Credit Card | Sam's Club® Mastercard® | |
Annual Fee | $0 ($60 Costco membership fee required) | $0
| $0 ($50/$110 for Club/Plus membership – MUST)
|
Rewards |
1-4%
4% cash back on on eligible gas and EV charging purchases for the first $7,000 per year and then 1% thereafter, 3% cash back on restaurants and most travel purchases, 2% cash back at Costco and Costco.com, 1% cash back on all other purchases
| 1% – 3%
3% cash back at Apple and select Apple pay partners. 3% Daily Cash back at Ace Hardware, Duane Reade, Exxon, Mobil, Nike, Panera Bread, T-Mobile, Uber, Uber Eats, and Walgreens. 2% on other Apple pay purchases, and 1% on all other purchases
|
1-5%
5% cash back on gas anywhere Mastercard is accepted (on the first $6,000 per year, then 1% after), 3% cash back on Sam’s Club purchases for Plus members, 3% on dining and takeout and 1% on all other purchases
|
Welcome bonus |
None
None
| N/A |
None
$30 statement credit after making $30 in Sam’s Club purchases within the first 30 days
|
Foreign Transaction Fee | $0
| $0 | N/A
|
Purchase APR | 19.99% – 27.99% (Variable)
| 15.99% – 26.99% Variable
| 20.40% or 28.40% Variable
|
Compare Target Red Card
While Target RedCard offers a less attractive cashback rewards ratio than Amazon, it still may be a better option for some. Let's compare.
If you focus on groceries – the Target RedCard wins, but if you focus on travel or gas – you may want the Costco credit card.
Target Red Card vs. Costco Anywhere Visa Card: How They Compare?
If you do all your grocery and fuel shopping at either Target or Sam's Club, the cashback you get from both credit cards is pretty similar.
The target RedCard is our clear winner, with a higher cash-back rate and estimated annual value. Here's what you can get with each card.
Compare Macy's Credit Card
The Macy's Credit Card is a clear winner with higher points rewards ratio and higher cashback value for the same spend than Nordstrom Card.
Nordstrom vs. Macy’s Credit Card: Which Store Card Gives You The Most Value?
The Macy's Credit Card is a clear winner with higher points rewards ratio and overall cashback value for the same spend than JCPenney Card.
Macy’s vs. JCPenney Credit Card: Which Gives You The Most Value?
Unlike Kohl's card, the Macy's Credit Card offers points rewards on all categories, making it more attractive for the average consumer.
Macy's Credit Card vs Kohl's Charge Card by Capital One: Which One Wins?
