Choosing the right bank account can feel overwhelming, especially with two prominent players, Bank of America and KeyBank. Both offer a range of products and services, but which one is the better fit for you? Let's dive into a detailed comparison to help you decide.
Checking Accounts
-
Account Types And Fees
KeyBank offers four main types of checking accounts, such as the Key Smart Checking and Key Select Checking, each catering to different needs:
KeyBank Account | Monthly Fee | Average Day Balance To Waive |
|---|---|---|
Key Smart Checking | $0 | N/A |
Key Select Checking | $25 | $15,000 |
KeyBank Hassle-Free Account | $0 | N/A |
BofA Checking Account | Monthly Fee | Average Day Balance To Waive |
|---|---|---|
Safe Balance | $4.95 | $500 |
Advantage Plus | $12 | $1,500 |
Advantage Relationship
| $25 | $20,000 |
-
Features
Bank of America offers some great features for both individuals and businesses.
Bank of America's basic accounts, such as the Safe Balance, offer digital banking convenience, with features like no overdraft fees and a $0 liability guarantee for enhanced security.
The Advantage Relationship account is a premium account that provides additional benefits, including interest earnings and fee exemptions for select banking services. Overdraft protection is also included, ensuring a more comprehensive and secure banking experience for customers.
BofA Checking Account | Main Features |
|---|---|
Safe Balance | Digital banking, no overdraft fees, $0 liability guarantee |
Advantage Plus | Paper checks, overdraft protection, $0 liability guarantee |
Advantage Relationship
| Earns interest, no fees on select banking service ,overdraft protection |
On the other hand, The KeyBank Smart Checking account provides convenient access to KeyBank and Allpoint ATMs, a Debit Mastercard, and the added benefit of Overdraft Protection. This account is ideal for those seeking a straightforward banking experience with essential features.
The Key Select Checking account is an interest-bearing option that allows customers to earn $100 each year with qualified direct deposits. This account is suitable for individuals who want to earn interest on their checking balance while enjoying the perks of a traditional checking account.
For those who prioritize simplicity, the KeyBank Hassle-Free Account offers mobile banking, Account Alerts, and EasyUp Automatic Savings. This account is designed for hassle-free banking, making it an excellent choice for those who value straightforward and convenient financial management.
KeyBank Bank Account | Main Features |
|---|---|
Key Smart Checking | Key and Allpoint ATMs, debit Mastercard, overdraft protection |
Key Select Checking | Interest bearing, $100 year after year with qualified direct deposits |
KeyBank Hassle-Free Account | Mobile banking, account alerts, EasyUp automatic savings |
Top Offers From Our Partners
Top Offers From Our Partners
Savings Accounts
KeyBank is our winner when it comes to savings.
The interest rates provided by Bank of America savings account and the Key Active Saver account are comparatively modest, falling below the rates available with other savings accounts.
However, KeyBank offers money market savings accounts with higher rates, which is not available through Bank of America.
KeyBank Active Saver | KeyBank Select MMA | BofA Savings | |
|---|---|---|---|
Savings Rate | N/A | 0.05% – 2.27% | 0.01% – 0.04% |
Minimum Deposit | $10 | $5,000 | $100 |
Fees | $4
Can be waived if you are an owner on a KeyBank consumer checking account
| $20
Can be waived if you have $25,000 minimum daily balance OR a relationship package checking account
| $8 per month
Can be waived by maintaining a balance of $500+, becoming a Preferred Rewards member or linking to your B of A Advantage Banking account. Fees are also waived for enrolled students aged under 24
|
Certificate Of Deposits (CDs)
When it comes to CDs, there is no clear winner as both KeyBank and Bank Of America offer similar CD rates.
Both banks offer a variety of terms of up to 10 years, but only special CDs with specific terms earn a competitive rate. With KeyBank, customers can earn the Relationship Reward rate (the highest rate) when have a Key checking account
-
Bank of America CD Rates
CD Term | APY |
|---|---|
3 Months | 3.75% |
6 Months | 0.03% |
7 Months (Featured) | 3.80% |
12 Months | 0.03% |
13 Months (Featured) | 2.75% |
24 Months | 0.03% |
25 Months (Featured) | 2.00% |
36 Months | 0.03% |
-
KeyBank CD Rates
Top Offers From Our Partners
Credit Cards
Card | Rewards | Bonus | Annual Fee |
| Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards
| 1.5%
unlimited 1.5% cash back on all purchases
| $200
$200 online cash rewards bonus after you make at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening.
| $0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards credit card | 1-3%
3% cash back in the category of your choice: gas, online shopping, dining, travel, drug stores, or home improvement/furnishings, 2% cash back at grocery stores and wholesale clubs and 1% cash back on all other purchases. The 3% and 2% cash back available on the first $2,500 in combined choice category/grocery store/wholesale club purchases each quarter (then 1%)
| $200
$200 cash rewards bonus after making at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of your account opening
| $0 |
| Bank of America® Travel Rewards credit card | 1.5X
1.5 points for every $1 you spend on all purchases everywhere, every time and no expiration on points
| 25,000 points
25,000 online bonus points after you make at least $1,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening – which can be redeemed for a $250 statement credit toward travel purchases
| $0 |
| BankAmericard | N/A | 21 billing cycles on purchases and balance transfers made within the first 60 days | $0 |
| Bank of America® Premium Rewards® Elite | 1.5x – 2x
2 points for every dollar you spend on travel or dining purchases, with 1.5 points per dollar on all your other purchases | 75,000 points
75,000 bonus points if you spend $5,000 or more within 90 days of opening your account
| $550 |
| Bank of America Premium Rewards | 1.5X – 2X
Unlimited 2X points on travel and dining purchases. Unlimited 1.5X points on all other purchases | 60,000 points
60,000 online bonus points after spending $4,000 on purchases in the first 90 days.
| $95 |
Card | Rewards | Bonus | Annual Fee |
| Key Cashback Credit Card
| 2%
2% on every purchase—no categories, no limits | 0% Intro APR: 12 billing cycles on balance transfers | $0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| KeyBank Latitude Credit Card | N/A | 0% Intro APR: 15 billing cycles on purchases and balance transfers | $0 |
| Key2More Rewards Credit Card | 5x
5 points for every $1 spent on eligible credit card purchases, no caps | 0% Intro APR: 6 billing cycles on purchases and balance transfers | $0 |
| Key Secured Credit Card | N/A | N/A | $0 |
Mortgage And Loans
KeyBank is our winner when it comes to lending options, as it offers more options for borrowers than Bank of America.
KeyBank provides a diverse array of loan options to address various financial needs. These include mortgages for homebuyers, mortgage refinancing for improved terms, and home equity loans or lines of credit for leveraging property equity.
The bank also offers personal loans for home improvement projects and car financing for both new and used vehicles. Additionally, KeyBank assists individuals in managing student loans through refinancing services, potentially lowering interest rates or adjusting repayment terms.
Bank of America lending options include offers mortgages, mortgage refinancing, and home equity loans. Additionally, they offer auto purchase loans and auto refinancing options.
Which Bank Is Our Winner?
In our opinion, Bank Of America is the preferred option in this battle, mainly due to its lead in checking accounts and credit cards. That being said, KeyBank offers better conditions for savers and borrowers.
Yet, choosing between them requires considering your needs—like banking services, overdraft support, ATM convenience, and location proximity. Different factors matter to different people, so take your time to evaluate what's essential for you before making a decision.
Understanding Our Banking Comparison Methodology
In our thorough banking comparison, The Smart Investor team carefully reviewed and compared banks across five key categories:
Checking Accounts (30%): We examined features like direct deposit, debit card availability, monthly fees, ATM and branch access, check deposit, bill pay options, and account alerts. We also considered any special offers available to customers.
Savings Accounts and CDs (20%): Our focus was on important factors such as the Annual Percentage Yield (APY), minimum deposit requirements, account flexibility, FDIC insurance coverage, special savings offers, variety of CDs, automatic renewal options, and early withdrawal penalties.
Credit Cards (15%): We analyzed rewards programs, annual fees, introductory bonuses, travel benefits, APR, and balance transfer options offered by each bank's credit cards to provide a comprehensive comparison of available features.
Lending Options (15%): We assessed the variety of loan options provided, including personal loans, student loans, mortgages, secured loans, HELOCs, and Home Equity Loans, offering insights into the banks' lending capabilities.
Customer Experience and Bank Reputation (20%): Our evaluation included an analysis of online banking and mobile app usability and ratings, accessibility of customer support, online reviews, JD Power research, Trustpilot ratings, and overall financial stability, providing a holistic view of customer experience and reputation.
Compare KeyBank Versus Other Banks
There is no clear winner in this battle as both banks offer similar bank account types. But what about the rest? Here's our winner: U.S. Bank vs. KeyBank
Both KeyBank and PNC Bank are active in various states, such as Pennsylvania, Indiana, Ohio, and more. Let's compare their banking products.
Compare BofA With Alternative Banks
Since its inception as a credit card provider, Discover has come a long way.Of course, credit cards are available, but you can also get home loans, personal loans, and a variety of checking and savings products such as retirement accounts, CDs, and money market accounts.
Bank of America offers a far more comprehensive range of banking services. There are numerous credit card options, as well as various savings and checking accounts.
Bank of America also provides mortgages, auto loans, and investments. This makes switching from a traditional bank much easier because you won't have to compromise on your banking products.
Read Full Comparison: Discover vs Bank of America: Compare Bank
Bank of America is a nationwide network that offers deposit, loan, and credit card services. There are also increased daily limits on ATM and debit purchases, which is an excellent incentive to improve your financial situation. Aspiration's company was presented in a very different manner than their bank competitors.
One feature that sets them apart from their competitors is that they let their customers decide how much they want to pay for their services. The fee that the customer believes is fair or appropriate for the level of service they receive is set by the customer.
Wells Fargo's product offering is even more extensive. This bank offers checking accounts, a variety of savings accounts, mortgages, loans, and investment options such as IRAs, 401ks, and wealth management services. This makes switching from another bank even easier because you'll have access to all of your favorite banking products.
Bank of America offers a diverse range of banking services. Checking and savings accounts, auto loans, home loans, credit cards, and investment options are all available.
Read Full Comparison: Bank of America vs Wells Fargo: Which Bank Is Better?
Bank of America has an impressive line of banking products, as one would expect from a large banking institution. Aside from various checking and savings accounts, there are auto loans, home loans, a variety of credit cards, and investment options. This makes switching from your current bank easier because you'll find many familiar products.
Chase also has a good selection of banking products. There are checking and savings accounts, auto loans, home loans, and home equity options, as well as a fantastic selection of credit cards.
Read Full Comparison: Bank of America vs Chase: Where to Save Your Money?
US Bank offers an even more impressive range of banking services. Savings and checking account options, investments, personal loans, mortgage products, and wealth management are all available.
Bank of America offers a wide range of banking services. There are numerous credit cards available, as well as various checking and savings accounts, home loans, investments, and auto loans.
Read Full Comparison: Bank of America vs US Bank: Which is Best For You?
Bank of America is a large banking institution, and its impressive banking product line reflects this. Aside from savings and checking accounts, there are home loans, auto loans, investment options, and a variety of credit cards. Citi also has a diverse product offering. Credit cards, CDs, personal loans, mortgages, IRAs, investment options, wealth management plans, and checking and savings accounts are all available.
As a result, if you want to switch from your current bank, either bank is a viable option because you won't have to make any compromises in terms of banking products.
Read Full Comparison: Bank of America vs Citi: Which Bank Suits You Best?
Spend and Save is a SoFi savings and checking account hybrid. For the purposes of this comparison, we'll look at the savings features, of which there are a few. The most visible are the savings vaults. These enable you to set up separate funds to work toward different savings goals without the need for multiple accounts. This helps you organize your money, and you can even designate a vault for your round-up funds.
Bank of America offers a more traditional savings account, but it pays far less interest, ranging from 0.01 percent to 0.04 percent depending on your Preferred Rewards status, compared to SoFi's 0.25 percent. In addition, there is a $8 monthly maintenance fee that can be waived by keeping a balance of $500 or more in the account or linking your checking account. By linking your accounts, you can avoid going overdrawn with Balance Connect.
Read Full Comparison: SoFi Money vs Bank of America: Which Is Better For Your Needs?
Both banks have a decent selection of banking products, but there are some gaps in each line up. If you’re looking for the best returns, Capital One does have the edge in terms of CD and savings rates.
There is no clear winner as to whether Truist Bank or Bank of America is a better choice, but we prefer the latter. Here's why.
Truist Bank vs. Bank Of America: Which Bank Account Is Better?
Bank of America and PNC Bank offer various banking products, but which is a better fit for you? Let's compare and see our winner: PNC Bank vs. Bank Of America
We'll explore Bank Of America and TD Bank savings accounts, checking accounts, CDs, credit cards, and lending products. Here's our winner: TD Bank vs. Bank Of America
BMO is the winner when it comes to savings products, while Bank Of America offers many more credit card options. Here's our winner: Bank of America vs. BMO Bank
There is no clear-cut winner, but we prefer Bank Of America. But, there are cases when Citizens is best. Here's our comparison: Bank of America vs. Citizens Bank
While Bank of America and Fifth Third Bank offer a range of banking services, Fifth Third is our winner in this competition. Here's why.
Bank of America vs. Fifth Third Bank: Which Bank Account Is Better?
We'll explore Bank of America and M&T Bank savings accounts, checking accounts, CDs, credit cards, and lending products. Here's our winner: Bank of America vs. M&T Bank
While Regions Bank offers better checking accounts, Bank of America wins in credit cards and CDs. Here's our side by side comparison: Regions Bank vs. Bank of America
If you feel comfortable with online-only banking and depending on your needs – Ally may be a better option than Bank Of America. Here's why.
Ally Bank vs. Bank of America: Which Bank Account Is Better?
For most consumers, Bank of America may be a better option. American Express is a solid option for customers with higher wealth. Here's why.
American Express Bank vs. Bank of America: Which Bank Account Is Better?
